Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
About
Matt's Cookie Company
Welcome to the delightful world of Matt's Cookie Company, a gem nestled in Wheeling, Illinois. With a commitment to crafting delicious and wholesome cookies, Matt's is rapidly gaining recognition—one satisfied cookie lover at a time. If you’re on the hunt for treats that taste like they came straight from Grandma’s kitchen, you've come to the right place.
Located at 482 N Milwaukee Ave, Wheeling, IL 60090, Matt's Cookie Company offers a range of cookies that cater to various dietary needs, including non-dairy options. Customers like Richard Ahern rave about their scrumptious oatmeal raisin cookies, praising their soft texture and wholesome ingredients. It's not just about taste; it’s about a feeling, and Richard’s review encapsulates the joy that comes from biting into a freshly baked cookie.
The highlight of Matt's offering extends beyond just cookies. Their fig bars have captivated customers such as Cindy C and Patti Beitzel who appreciate the clean, short ingredient lists. Patti, in particular, highlights their health-conscious appeal, proving that indulging in a snack can still align with a clean-eating lifestyle. This sentiment resonates with anyone who believes that cookies can be both tasty and nutritious.
Another standout product is their peanut butter cookies, described as super moist and flavorful by Chanel Palmer. Her enthusiasm for these cookies is palpable, transforming her into a dedicated fan eager to explore more flavors. This is the hallmark of Matt's—cookies that create loyal followers, one bite at a time.
Not to be overlooked, the rave reviews from longtime customers like Uncle Zepol showcase the consistency and quality Matt’s delivers. He reflects on nearly a decade of devoted cookie munching, particularly singling out their cranberry walnut cookies as sublime. His excitement and loyalty underscore why Matt's Cookie Company has become a staple for cookie lovers across the nation.
While Matt's Cookie Company might be a bit of a hidden treasure, it's clear that its products create a sense of nostalgia and comfort, evoking memories of home-cooked goodness. The blend of natural ingredients and careful craftsmanship ensures each cookie is not just a snack, but a delightful experience. So, whether you’re local or exploring from afar, make sure to give Matt's cookies a try! You might just find your new favorite indulgence. Reach out directly at +1 847-537-3888 for inquiries or to learn more about their offerings.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ I saw the overall average and it was so low I had to help rectify that. These cookies were delicious and soft (oatmeal raisin) and non-dairy. Perfect for me. Never heard of them and I grew up in the Chicago area. Menards has them in Minnesota. ”
“ Amazing cookies. They taste like they were made with real ingredients in someone's home kitchen. Looking at the short list of ingredients, I understood. I tried the fig bars on impulse and was honestly blown away by the taste. Enough that I am very much looking forward to trying the other varieties. For now though, I'm sticking with the fig bars that are my new favorite. ”
“ I have had to start eating clean because of my health. Most fig bars will make me very ill because of all the processed ingredients. Matt's Fig Bars are delicious and I can eat them any time i want and not be sick. I am hoping to keep buying them on a regular basis. ”
“ I just wanted to reach out and comment on your product. I recently purchased Matt's peanut butter cookies, and I have never tasted a cookie like this. It was super moist and flavorful. They tasted like a homemade cookie. These cookies made me go back to my local ShopRite and purchase all the remaining boxes. I would have never thought a cookie made from so far away would be about to retain its texture and flavor. I am excited to try the other flavors. A new fan from New Jersey!!!! ”
“ This company has the best cookies in the whole world. The taste and texture are perfect. We've been eating these cookies off and on for nearly 10 years now. I just ordered 11 bags and we're ready to munch out on Matt's cookies. The cranberry walnut cookies are off the chart goodness. I want them all for me !!! The best soft baked and all natural cookie on the market. ”
“ I got the Peanut and Chocolate Chip cookies from Whole Foods and I am a fan! Especially after you heat them up a little to get the chocolate to melt. I didn't really read the label, just wanted a soft baked peanut butter cookie. And these are really good! I just saw that they are dairy free and I'm even more impressed by the taste and texture. Can't wait to try the other flavors. ”
“ These cookies are by far the best we've ever had. It's a pure treat and delight for me and my husband. Matt's cookies are deliciously soft and moist and better than homemade cookies. We've tried others and we always come back to Matt's cookies. We especially love their Double Chocolate Peppermint cookies. They are becoming a staple in our home along with their other flavorful cookies. ”
“ I just tried the soft baked chocolate peanut butter cookies for the first time yesterday....and I. Am. In. Love!!! The little peanut pieces. The shape of the cookies that look like they were scooped and baked by hand. The texture. The flavor. These are the store bought cookies that taste home made I have been looking for. Can't wait to try the other flavors. ”